Ranking the Pac-10 defensive tackles

July 22, 2008 2:51 PM

Posted by ESPN.com's Ted Miller

Moving on to defense, this is a strange one.

Guess how many defensive tackles from the 2007 All-Pac-10 First and Second Teams and honorable mentions are back this fall?

Zero.

That means the No. 1 guy on this list, USC's Fili Moala, didn't get a single vote from conference coaches last year.

Nonetheless, he's expected to be a first-round pick in the 2009 NFL draft. Go figure.

If there is any one position where the Pac-10 is consistently lacking -- and falls way short of the SEC -- it's defensive tackle. That is, of course, outside of USC; think that might be meaningful?

The position doesn't actually get that much respect in the conference. Of the eight defensive linemen honored as First- or Second-Team All-Pac-10, only two -- USC's Sedrick Ellis (duh) and Arizona's Lionel Dotson -- were DTs and not sack-producing DEs.

A lot of that is DEs put up impressive sack stats in a pass-happy conference. But a run-stuffing DT who also can collapse a pocket is a presence that transforms a good defense into a great one.

And most prognosticators don't think the Pac-10 will have a great defense this fall. Other, of course, than said Trojans.

  1. Fili Moala, Sr., USC: Got to be honest: I thought Moala was just the guy who played beside Sedrick Ellis and Lawrence Jackson in 2007, but he apparently will be a first-round draft pick this spring. In fact, Todd McShay has him going No. 1 overall.
  2. Ekom Udofia, Jr., Stanford: A touted recruit in 2005, he appears poised for a breakout. The 310-pounder is already appearing on a few 2009 draft lists.
  3. Brigham Harwell, Sr., UCLA: A knee injury ended his 2007 season, but he's a high-motor guy who's started for three years.
  4. Brian Price, So. UCLA: Got double-teamed as a true freshman; he's a budding star. Don't be shocked if he ends up First-Team All-Pac-10.
  5. Averell Spicer, Jr., USC: Starting on USC's DL is, in itself, meaningful. Spicer flashed some play-making ability in 2007 and this past spring. A hard worker with skills.
  6. Ra'Shon Harris, Sr., Oregon: He's got the size at 6-foot-5, 321 pounds. He just needs to use it more.
  7. Derrick Hill, So., California: Played well late in 2007, so the former elite recruit should push past Mika Kane on the depth chart and become the noseguard when the Bears use a new 3-4 look.
  8. David Smith, Sr., Arizona State: A lunch-pail guy who started 13 games in 2007 and made 6.5 tackles for loss.
  9. Pernnell Booth, Sr., Oregon State: Three tackles for loss last year. If healthy, he's solid.
  10. Fevaea'i Ahmu, Sr., Washington State: He's experienced but he's battled injuries throughout his career.

Pac-10 general, USC Trojans, Fili Moala, Stanford Cardinal, Ekom Udofia, UCLA Bruins, Brigham Harwell, Brian Price, Averell Spicer, Oregon Ducks, Ra'Shon Harris, California Bears, Derrick Hill, Arizona State Sun Devils, David Smith, Oregon State Beavers, Pernnell Booth, Washington State Cougars, Fevaea'i Ahmu

Sort comments by: Most Recent | First Posted